Key West packs its secondhand book hunting into a few Old Town blocks. Fleming Street holds every stop on this page: an independent shop selling new, used and rare books, founded in 1976 by its own account, plus the county library branch a couple of blocks east, where volunteers from the Friends group sell donated books both indoors and out in the garden.
None of the three stops lies more than a mile from City Hall on White Street, so a morning on foot or on a rented bike covers them all. This guide turned up no used bookshop or book-carrying thrift on Stock Island, Key Haven or Big Coppitt Key, and Big Pine Key, farther up the Overseas Highway, lies outside the area covered here.
Winter is the season to plan around, since the Friends say they hold their outdoor garden sales between December and March. Outside those months, the bookshop's trade counter and the library's indoor shelves keep things moving.
New, used and rare bookshopKey West Island Books
513 1/2 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040
Its website dates the business to 1976 and bills it as Key West's oldest independent bookstore; the shop stands on Fleming Street in Old Town, a straight-line 0.9 miles west-northwest of the White Street City Hall, and the site listed author signings there from November 21, 2025 to January 23, 2026. Next to bestsellers and a big local-authors section, the site promises used books in all categories, rare and antiquarian stock, signed first editions and Hemingway titles that include rare first printings of his work. Clean used books can be swapped for trade credit with no expiry date, good for anything on the shelves or a special order, though ex-library and water-damaged copies are refused and drop-offs should be booked by phone. The contact page gives a 6pm Sunday close but prints the Sunday opening as 12:00 AM, so call 305-294-2904 before a Sunday visit.
Hours: Mon–Sat 10am–8pmWebsite Friends' garden book saleFriends of the Key West Library Palm Garden book sales
Key West Library, 700 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040
In the garden of the Monroe County library branch on Fleming Street, a 0.7-mile hop from City Hall, Friends of the Key West Library volunteers set out roughly 3,000 donated books at outdoor sales that, on their book-sales page, run monthly from December through March, with "always a line of customers waiting for the gates to open." A post on the Friends' website dated November 2, 2026 listed the coming season's four dates, and the group's events calendar gives each sale a 10am start and a 1pm close. Money raised helps fund the library's programs for children and adults.
Hours: Next sale: Sat Dec 5, 2026, 10am–1pm; then Sat Jan 2, Sat Feb 6 and Sat Mar 6, 2027, 10am–1pmWebsite Where can I find cheap used books in Key West?
At the library on Fleming Street. Outside the winter garden sales, the Friends' indoor shelves run on cash donations dropped in a box, and in season their Palm Garden tables add thousands more donated books. Key West Island Books is where to look for rare and Hemingway titles.
Where do I sell used books in Key West?
Key West Island Books takes clean used books in trade, settling in shop credit instead of cash, and prefers you ring ahead of turning up with a full tote. For anything you would rather turn into money, point BiblioScan at the shelf for one shot: it tags every spine it spots with a probable resale figure, so the keepers for an online listing separate themselves from the trade-in and Friends-donation pile.
Which day is best for book hunting in Key West?
Saturday, especially in winter: the Friends' current calendar has every garden sale falling on a Saturday, while the library's indoor shelves and Key West Island Books are both open that day. On Sundays the library stays shut; the bookshop does post Sunday hours, but its listed opening time looks garbled, so phone before going.
When is the Friends of the Library sale in Key West?
The library's Friends group describes its Palm Garden sales as monthly from December to March, at 700 Fleming Street, and posts each season's dates on its website and events calendar. Outside that window, the group's honor-box shelves inside the library cover the gap.