Crime and horror specialistMurder and Mayhem
5 Lion St, Hay-on-Wye, Hereford HR3 5AA
Opposite Addyman Books on Lion Street, the crime shop the same owners opened in 1997: detective fiction, true crime and horror filed A to Z, with deep shelves of green Penguins, Agatha Christie and Sherlock Holmes. WalesOnline sent true-crime readers here in a feature published on 3 September 2025. The 2026–2027 leaflet says it gladly buys crime paperbacks, some hardbacks, horror and true crime, and opens Monday to Saturday with some Sundays in season.
Golden Age crime shopChristie & Doyle
4 Lion St, Hay-on-Wye, Hereford HR3 5AA
Next door to Murder and Mayhem on Lion Street, billed in the 2026–2027 booksellers' leaflet as the fourth episode in the Addyman story and a sequel to its crime shop; BBC Hereford & Worcester ran a short piece on it on 13 January 2026, describing it as a shop given over to Agatha Christie. The shelves keep to Golden Age detection, with Agatha Christie and Arthur Conan Doyle at the centre and a large cosy crime section. The leaflet prints no opening hours for this one, and enquiries go through the shared Addyman email address.
Second-hand bookshopsThe Addyman Annexe
27 Castle St, Hay-on-Wye, Hereford HR3 5DF
Castle Street, roughly 200 yards west of the centre, and the third Addyman shop, which the owners say followed Murder and Mayhem by five years and covers beat, art, modern firsts, poetry, philosophy and left-wing history. The 2026–2027 leaflet adds travel and topography, history, military, a children's corner selling new books at half price, and a paperback room it ranks among the country's strongest. The leaflet credits the Antiquarian Book Review with naming it the jewel in the crown of the book town, a phrase WalesOnline repeated without attribution on 20 September 2026.
Science fiction and fantasy specialistBookshop 451
10 High Town, Hay-on-Wye HR3 5AE
Named after the Bradbury novel, and reported as newly opened by the Green Ink team in the Brecon & Radnor Express on 21 April 2026. Science fiction and fantasy take most of the room, with romantasy, horror, graphic novels, YA, and first editions and collectable copies alongside. Would-be sellers are asked to email the number of books, subjects and condition, ideally with a picture or two showing the spines.
Second-hand bookshopsHay-on-Wye Booksellers
13-14 High Town, Hay-on-Wye HR3 5AE
A general shop at 13–14 High Town whose stock, as listed in the 2026–2027 leaflet, runs from antiquarian and secondhand to new books at half price or less, with a large clearance section. Its advert in the town's 2026 visitor guide promises cash for quality antiquarian and secondhand books and a willingness to travel anywhere for a library. The leaflet gives every day from 10:30am to 4pm as its hours, and the firm runs a separate trade warehouse on Gypsy Castle Lane for dealers.
Multi-dealer book centreBroad Street Book Centre
6 Broad St, Hay-on-Wye, Hereford HR3 5DB
A building of rented units on Broad Street, where the 2026–2027 leaflet lists separate dealers for railways, military history, science fiction, modern firsts, books about books and Herefordshire history from the local publisher Logaston Press, among others. In a Facebook post of 14 April 2026 the centre was looking for booksellers to take a large area coming free, noting that its doors open daily and that it handles all internet sales for its tenants. One of those tenants, Bedlam Books and Music, also sells CDs at two for £5 according to the leaflet.
Second-hand bookshopsClock Tower Books
5 Market St, Hay-on-Wye, Hereford HR3 5AF
Market Street, with stock pooled from several booksellers and summed up on its Instagram profile as secondhand, antiquarian and some new books on most subjects. An Instagram post of 6 February 2026 showed off its white shelving with a caption asking who said secondhand bookshops should be dark and dull, and the County Times placed it in a top five of Hay bookshops by Google reviews on 7 May 2025. The leaflet points to Ladybird books, annuals, Folio Society, railways, beekeeping and country life among its sections.
Poetry specialistThe Poetry Bookshop
Cranbourne House, The Pavement, Lion St, Hay-on-Wye HR3 5BU
Devoted to poetry since 1979 by its own account, and housed in Cranbourne House on The Pavement, which its advert in the 2026 visitor guide places next to the clocktower. Antiquarian, secondhand and out-of-print poetry makes up most of the shelves, new poetry has been added for the first time since the founders' day, and the shop buys good-quality secondhand poetry once it has seen the books. Its website posted a tribute on 9 March 2026 to Glenn Storhaug of Five Seasons Press, linked to the shop since its foundation. Confirm the days before you go: the site's banner reads Monday to Saturday, 11am to 1pm and 2pm to 5pm, while the 2026–2027 leaflet says Wednesday to Saturday, 11am to 5pm.
Natural history specialistC. Arden, Bookseller
The Nursery, Forest Rd, Hay-on-Wye HR3 5DT
A bookroom at The Nursery on Forest Road, about a quarter-mile south of the town centre and, by its own advert, 150 metres from the main car park, holding roughly 15,000 books on the shop's count. Natural history leads, with Collins' New Naturalist series, entomology, ornithology, botany, gardening and beekeeping, and forthcoming New Naturalist titles sold by subscription at 25% off the cover price. The 2026 visitor guide and the 2026–2027 leaflet agree with the website on weekday opening plus Saturday mornings, and the shop says it is happy to view and buy within its specialisms.
Hours: Mon–Fri 9:30am–5pm, Sat 9:30am–noonWebsite Children's books specialistThe Children's Bookshop
Toll Cottage, Pontvaen, Hay-on-Wye HR3 5EW
Over the border in Clifford parish, Herefordshire, three-quarters of a mile north-north-east of the centre on the B4350 past the Co-op: a cottage with its own parking that has specialised in children's literature since 1978 and reports a stock above 20,000 titles. Its selling page is precise: it buys secondhand children's and young adult books but not adult titles, and pays £1 per hardback and 50p per paperback for bulk lots arriving without an appointment or a list. It wants a plain-text email with title, author, publisher and date ahead of a visit, and it does not usually collect. WalesOnline named it among Hay's specialist shops on 20 September 2026.
Hours: Tue–Sat 10:30am–5:30pmWebsite Comic shopHay-on-Wye Comics
23 Castle St, Hay-on-Wye HR3 5DF
A comics and graphic-novel shop selling new, secondhand and independent titles, from back issues and manga to children's graphic novels. It began as a concession inside the Broad Street Book Centre, which welcomed it on Facebook in May 2024, before moving into its own premises, and WalesOnline listed it among Hay's specialists on 20 September 2026. Its website keeps Monday and Tuesday closed, while the booksellers' leaflet for 2026–2027 says the doors open every day in season.
Hours: Wed–Sat 10:30am–5pm, Sun 10:30am–4pmWebsite