Where to buy used books in Eureka

Updated 11/17/2026

Every distance below starts at Eureka City Hall at 531 K Street, on Humboldt Bay in California’s far north, and the circle reaches about 15 miles out: Arcata, the college town roughly 6 miles to the northeast, plus Fortuna to the south. Old Town is the core of the trip, since two independent bookstores share the 400 block of Second Street there, and a few blocks east the volunteers behind the county library system keep a small shop one flight up in the main library and stage their larger sales in the same building.

Arcata adds Tin Can Mailman, a used bookstore that traces its roots back to 1972, and the Friends of its branch library have staged sales too. Out on Broadway, the Eureka Rescue Mission’s thrift lists books with the rest of its donated goods, and Fortuna’s library Friends have also paired a book sale with a fundraising dinner. Several of the Arcata and Old Town shops that come up in searches turn out to sell new books, games or comics, and those are listed in the tips below.

Spot map

The best spots

Used, new and antiquarian bookstore

Eureka Books

426 2nd St, Eureka, CA 95501

Since 1987 this store has sold used, new and rare books along with prints and maps from a Victorian storefront in Old Town, less than half a mile west-northwest of City Hall, while its about page adds book-adjacent goods and even kites to the mix. Checked by this guide on November 17, 2026, that page also notes that a spin-off called Omnibus opened in March 2026 at 117 F Street to take over the manga, comics, graphic novels and role-playing games. Selling here is by appointment: the shop buys used books in all subjects paying either cash or credit with no expiry date, accepts no more than three bags or boxes at once, generally prefers paperbacks to hardcovers and refuses textbooks, ex-library copies and anything marked up.

Hours: Mon–Thu 10am–6pm, Fri–Sat 10am–8pm, Sun 10am–5pmWebsite
Friends of the Library bookstore

Serendipity Book Store (Friends of the Redwood Libraries)

Eureka Main Library, 1313 3rd St, Eureka, CA 95501

Upstairs in the main branch of the Humboldt County Library, roughly 380 yards northeast of City Hall, sits a shop that the Friends of the Redwood Libraries staff and describe as "the Little Store on the Second Floor," stocked with books, magazines, CDs and DVDs and topped up with new inventory every day. The group says the shop opened in October 1999 and has passed $500,000 in sales, and it also sells vintage and antique titles online through AbeBooks and Amazon. In mid-November 2026 the group’s home page offered its 2027 children’s art calendar for $10 at this counter, and every young artist who entered received a certificate good for free books here.

Hours: Tue noon–4:30pm, Wed noon–7:30pm, Thu noon–4:30pm, Fri 10am–4:30pm, Sat 11am–3:30pmWebsite
Used and rare bookstore

Tin Can Mailman

1000 H St, Arcata, CA 95521

In Arcata, roughly 6 miles northeast of Eureka’s City Hall, this used, rare and textbook shop says it has served the North Coast since 1972, when its founder stocked fruit crates nailed to a wall with 400 borrowed books and named the business after Tonga’s Tin Can Mail Island. Its store page, unchanged in Wayback Machine captures from January 2026 onward, announces winter hours with the store closed on Wednesdays. Selling or trading requires an appointment and no more than two banker boxes, store credit runs at twice the cash offer, and a photo ID is needed to be paid in cash.

Hours: Mon–Tue 11am–6pm, Thu 11am–6pm, Fri–Sat 11am–7pm, Sun noon–6pm; closed WedWebsite

All spots by type

Used bookstores

Used bookstore

Booklegger

402 2nd St, Eureka, CA 95501

A few doors from Eureka Books on the same Old Town block, Booklegger appears in the Visit Eureka shopping guide as "a classic used bookstore packed with affordable treasures," with fiction, nonfiction and work by local authors on the shelves. The shop made the news on August 5, 2026, when Lost Coast Outpost ran the headline "A Man Who Shoplifted From Booklegger in Eureka 40 Years Ago Just Mailed the Book Back With an Apology and a $100 Bill." Opening times are another matter: the shop posts none this guide was able to locate, so call first rather than count on a set schedule.

Thrift stores & charity shops

Charity thrift store (Eureka Rescue Mission)

Rescue Mission Thrift Store

1031 Broadway St, Eureka, CA 95501

On Broadway, a straight-line 0.8 miles to the west-southwest of City Hall, the Eureka Rescue Mission’s store lists books next to clothing, shoes, furniture, housewares, toys and electronics, new or gently used, wording that a Wayback Machine capture from July 2026 also shows. Sales fund the mission’s Men’s Shelter and its Women & Children’s Shelter, and stock changes from one day to the next. The doors open Tuesday through Saturday, with donations taken until 4:45pm.

Hours: Tue–Sat 10am–5:15pmWebsite

Library book sales

Library book sales

Friends of the Redwood Libraries Book Sales

Eureka Main Library, 1313 3rd St, Eureka, CA 95501

Beyond the upstairs shop, the same Friends group put on four sales at the main library in 2026, according to the county library’s events calendar: a spring sale in April, a $2-a-bag sale in July that the listing billed as annual and as the group’s biggest of the year, a one-day fiction clearance with everything at 50 cents in late August, and an October sale. For that last one, fiction filled the library garage while nonfiction such as cookbooks, military history and art went into the meeting room, and the Friends’ price list put a hardcover at $1, a paperback at half that and a disc or record at a quarter. Friday is reserved for members, though a membership can be taken out right there, and as of mid-November 2026, this guide found the group’s sale page still without a date for the next one.

Hours: Last documented: Fri Oct 9, 2026, 10am–3:30pm (members); Sat Oct 10, 2026, 10am–3:30pmWebsite
Library book sales

Friends of the Arcata Library Book Sale

Arcata Library, 500 7th St, Arcata, CA 95521

Also in Arcata, a few blocks from Tin Can Mailman, the volunteer nonprofit backing the town’s branch library raises money for books and materials that the library budget does not cover. Its most recent sale this guide could trace fell on Saturday, June 20, 2026, at the branch itself, as announced on KHSU’s community calendar, with proceeds earmarked for titles on the librarian’s wish list. On the Friends’ own site this guide found nothing scheduled after it, and that site calls the future of their sales uncertain, with donations suspended for lack of space, though it still points to books on display in the branch, paid for on an honor system.

Hours: Last documented: Sat Jun 20, 2026, 11am–4pmWebsite
Library book sales

Friends of the Fortuna Library: Library Day Book Sale

Fortuna Veterans Memorial Building, 1426 Main St, Fortuna, CA 95540

Down in Fortuna, about 14 miles due south of Eureka’s City Hall, Fortuna’s library Friends combined a book sale with a drive-thru dinner for Library Day on Saturday, March 14, 2026, at the town’s Veterans Memorial Building. The county’s library calendar promised great titles at bargain prices from morning to evening, while chicken cacciatore to go cost $25 a person or $40 a couple, booked through the library. The branch page adds that the Friends take used book donations during open hours, with a limit of two bags or boxes daily, and no encyclopedias, textbooks or Reader’s Digests.

Hours: Last documented: Sat Mar 14, 2026, 10am–7pmWebsite

Scan before you buy

At every one of these spots, snap the shelf with BiblioScan: the AI identifies each book and shows its real resale price. Walk out with profitable books, not random boxes.

Or try BiblioScan free on the web →

Local sourcing tips

  • Found Curated Thrift, a nonprofit with stores in Fortuna on South Fortuna Boulevard, in Old Town Eureka on F Street and in Arcata on 8th Street, funds monthly grants for people in the community, yet this guide found its website silent about books. The same goes for the Hospice Shop on H Street in Arcata, the American Cancer Society Discovery Shop on F Street in Eureka and the YouthAbility Thrift Shop in Arcata: worth a look on a thrift run, with no promise of a shelf of books.
  • A few Arcata and Old Town bookshops sell mainly new stock: Northtown Books, an Arcata bookstore since 1965 now at 737 G Street, Suite 1; next door, Dandar’s Boardgames and Books, which moved to a new permanent address after a fire on January 2, 2026, and stocks board games plus science fiction and fantasy books; and Omnibus, the Eureka Books spin-off on F Street for manga and comics. This guide found no statement of used stock from any of them, nor from Blake’s Books on Central Avenue in McKinleyville or the Buffalo Book Club on 13th Street in Fortuna.
  • The Humboldt County Historical Society runs a bookstore in its house at 703 8th Street, open Wednesday to Friday, and lists used books for sale on its website; call ahead to ask whether a specific one is on the premises.
  • Redwood Flea Market at the Redwood Acres Fairgrounds on Harris Street names books and comics among the goods its vendors bring and charges $3 cash at the door, but this guide found no posted days on its website, so follow its social pages before you go.
  • The Friends of the Ferndale Library raise money with book sales open to the community, according to the county’s Ferndale branch page, and North Coast Roleplaying on Broadway sells comics and graphic novels, though this guide saw no dated sale or back-issue bins for either. Cal Poly Humboldt’s Campus Store in Arcata is a college bookstore.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I find cheap used books in Eureka?

The library volunteers who staff Serendipity are the bargain end of town: their sales at the main library ask a dollar per hardback and two quarters per paperback, and the bag sale goes further. Between sales, the Serendipity shop upstairs stays open five days a week, and the Rescue Mission thrift on Broadway mixes books into its donated stock.

Where do I sell used books in Eureka?

Both Eureka Books in Old Town and Tin Can Mailman in Arcata buy over the counter, by appointment only, and both are choosy about condition. Eureka Books pays in cash or credit that never expires for up to three bags or boxes; Tin Can accepts at most two boxes per appointment and gives credit worth twice its cash price. Before booking a slot, point BiblioScan at the stacked spines; it prices every visible title from that one photo, so you know before the appointment which copies are worth selling yourself on the web.

Which day is best for book hunting in Eureka?

A Saturday run reaches the most counters, with Eureka Books open until 8pm, Tin Can Mailman until 7pm, the Rescue Mission thrift until 5:15pm and the Friends’ shop until 3:30pm. Sunday and Monday narrow the list to Eureka Books and Tin Can, because the library shop and the thrift store stay shut. On Wednesdays it flips: Tin Can’s winter schedule keeps it shut, while Serendipity keeps its counter open into the evening.

When is the Friends of the Library sale in Eureka?

Eureka’s library Friends announce each sale on the book sales page of their website, and the events calendar of the Humboldt County Library lists them as well; most of their sales open with a members-only day, though newcomers can sign up when they arrive. Fortuna’s and Arcata’s Friends groups announce their own sales through that county calendar and local community listings.

Before you go

Do you run a store here?

Bookstore, thrift store or consignment shop in Eureka: get listed in this guide for free, or tell us what to fix.

Contact us

Nearby cities